Okay, first I'd like to see him focus on comedy. Not with monkeys or banal kid fare, but the kind of stuff he had fun with during KF:TLC. Like Wolfe or the Hugh Grantesque discomfort with certain women scenes or his sassy, smart alecky wise cracks. I'd like to see him relax, have fun and push it.
Frankly, (and here's were I get yelled at by everyone), I'm ready for him to really challenge himself again.

I think the reason he was so dynamic in QAF was that he was uncomfortable. He was having to work beyond his comfort zone. This wasn't just another good-looking, 6 ft., WASP leading role and he couldn't just show up and read his lines competently. He had to make some tough choices and overcome his discomfort with the nudity and sexuality. So I'd like him to make a few choices based not on the money or the shooting location or the networking, but because he's passionate about the project and about his acting. He's certainly intelligent and educated enough to have handled his income well and should have the option of going for a role or two that causes butterflies in his stomach -- and in ours. And I think he could certainly take a strong, minor comedic character role, like Michael Keaton has done from time to time. I think it would do him and his career a lot of good -- and certainly brighten our days.
Okay, now everyone can commence to yell (quietly).
By the way, Whitehowler, great thread! Thanks!